The Hidden Cost Of Building The Wrong Team

In this episode, I cover the hidden cost of building the wrong team and how to stop putting square pegs in round holes. I explain why we hire for attitude, loyalty and availability instead of capability, and why promoting a great performer into a role that needs completely different skills can set them up to fail. I share how the wrong role damages a person’s confidence, their colleagues and your business, and why adaptability isn’t the same as aptitude. I also tell the story of the excellent admin assistant I hired early on, and what happened when I gave her work that suited me instead of her. Finally, I walk through how to build a team around strengths, and how to have the honest conversation when you’ve made a hiring mistake.

Read the full transcript

Ange Dove (00:08)

Just because someone is talented, loyal, and hardworking doesn't mean they're right for the role that you put them in. Now, while startups require people to be flexible and wear many hats, there's a difference between stretching someone's capabilities and setting them up for fail. So that's what we're talking about in today's You're the Boss podcast, is we're looking at putting stop how you would stop putting square pegs in round holes and really this becomes the hidden cost of building the wrong team.

Now, yes, when you're running a startup, it has to be lean. You've got to get people to do multiple things, but you've got to be strategic about it and you've got to realize the the core abilities or capabilities of individual members of your team and what you can put them in and what you absolutely cannot put them in. Because either

They're going to walk out the door and you've lost them, or it's going to be some kind of c catastrophe in the business because they're not going to be able to keep up.

So that's what we're talking about today. It's a fine line, but it's a really important one as you're starting a business and you're starting to grow a team. How do you do this with a lean team, but still having everybody working well together as a team, working individually well and It being able to help your business, not hinder it. All right. So are you setting your people up to fail? That's the question here. So if you've run a business before, this is a question for you. If you haven't and you're just starting out and you haven't hired anyone yet, you want to be thinking about this question. So if you've have you ever hired someone or moved someone into a role, knowing deep down they're probably not good for it.

And but you're trying to convince yourself that they are and it's all gonna work out magically, right? maybe they were loyal, maybe they were enthusiastic, or maybe you simply needed someone to get that particular role done, and they were the only available body in the room. And if you're running a startup, you probably told yourself, we're a small team, everyone has to wear different hats, right? It's a very common thought.

Ange Dove (02:30)

But this can actually destroy your business. So here's the thing. There's a big difference between asking someone to wear different hats and asking them to wear one that just doesn't fit at all. All right. You've still got to be, they've still got to be working around their capabilities. So when you put square pegs into round holes, I mean children learn this easy. You don't put a square peg into a round hole, it's not gonna fit, right? But so why as business owners do we try to do this, right?

It's not just that the business that will suffer either. the person, their confidence and their colleagues are it's it's going to impact all of them in every way. So today I want to talk about why we do this, the damage it causes, and why good leadership sometimes means admitting that we've put the right people in the wrong seat. You know, we talk about people on the bus, you've put them in the wrong seat on the bus kind of thing. So let's get into this. So why do we put square pegs in round holes? really the the the main reason is that we hire for attitude, loyalty, and availability rather than capability.

Now again, there's two sides to that coin and people will land on one side or the other. Yes, you know, people say you you hire for attitude and you train for capability. But my experience in running a business is yes, you hire for attitude. You want the right attitude, but you actually want them to be capable of doing the job as well. You do not want to be paying them a salary to train them and then realize afterwards that wasn't their aptitude. So you got to hire on attitude and aptitude. All right. And sometimes we promote good performers into roles requiring completely different skills.

Classic example of this would be a great salesperson. You have a great salesperson on your team, and you decide that they're such a great salesperson that they're the person to become the sales manager and lead the rest of the team and train the team to be exactly like them. Right. Now the skills of being a salesperson and the skills of being a leader of a team, two completely different things. If that salesperson doesn't have the skills to lead as a team,

Ange Dove (04:55)

you're setting them up for failure by promoting them into that role. You've got to be able to train them first to get ready to take that role on before you just lump them in it. Right. And sometimes we expect people to learn everything because we can't afford specialists, which is so true for small businesses, right? We can't afford to put, you know, a hire an expert in one area and just have them work on that and then hire another expert, just have them work on that.

And everyone's siloed and can do their jobs really well, but the expense to the company at a startup stage, that's too expensive. So we've got to kind of again draw the line and blur the line between hiring generalists and specialists, or hiring specialists and have them do other roles in the company just to help out and you know pull the load, right?

And sometimes we confuse enthusiasm and willingness with competence. So someone may be really, really gung-ho and yeah, I'm gonna do this, I wanna do this, I wanna help, but actually they just can't do the job that you're putting them in for. So again, look at what they can do and what they can't do and find roles for them that they can do. And then sometimes we avoid the difficult conversations because we like the person, we don't want to lose the person.

So, You know, what what I tried to do in in my company all the time was if I found that the wrong person was in the role, I would try to find them a role that would suit their capabilities. so I'm trying to justify why I should keep them on rather than admit that I made a hiring mistake. so if you can do that, if you can move them to a role that they're better suited to, that could benefit your business, you know, in leaps and bounds.

Do that if you can, rather than letting someone go. And we keep eventually hoping this is what this is the big mistake I made when I first started my business. I kind of had this crazy belief that I could train anybody to do anything. So as long as they were a breathing body and they came in and they were willing to work, then if I train them, they would be able to do the job. So you're hoping that eventually they'll grow into that role.

Ange Dove (07:20)

It's usually not gonna happen. It's usually not gonna happen. They have to have the capabilities and the personality traits to be able to handle that job in the first place. So yeah, so that that's that's why we end up with the problems that we end up with is we're trying to do these things usually to cut costs, usually to keep a lean team, and it can backfire. So just keep those.

Points in mind as you are making your hiring decisions. And, you know, so that's one side of it is, you know, just hiring wrong. And that person is going to be miserable if if they're in the wrong role, because then nobody wants to be in a role that they can't do and they feel miserable coming into work every day, knowing that they're not really contributing, they're just making a mess of things. Nobody wants to feel like that. So

The damage actually goes much deeper than just poor performance, right? So for the as I've just hinted at there, for the individual themselves, they begin to lose confidence in themselves. They may have come into your comp company really confident and you put them in the wrong role and you destroy that confidence completely. and they try to work harder and they try to please, but then they end up achieving less or making things worse.

And they feel constantly criticized or inadequate. And nobody, as I said, nobody wants to feel like this. even though they might be brilliant in a different role, you transfer them to a different role and they may absolutely shine. And for the team itself, it has an impact on the team as well. Colleagues have to pick up the slack of what this person can't do. Resentment grows, strong performers get frustrated because they're con con.

put my teeth in, they're constantly having to compensate for someone's someone else's lack of capability. And it's not that person's that other person's fault. It was your fault for putting them in the role in the first place. And for the business itself, there there's an impact to the business itself as well. So as mistakes multiply, you're gonna deliver less for the client, productivity will suffer, customers are going to notice things are being done wrong.

Ange Dove (09:44)

And then leaders in your team are firefighting instead of doing the job they're supposed to be doing themselves. So everybody suffers in that sense. So really the key thing here is you can take a perfectly capable, capable, talented person and make them feel completely inadequate and incompetent simply by putting them in the wrong job. Okay. So

You think about it that way, it's that's not a nice position to be in for anybody. So we want to avoid that.

So again, why does it happen? It's this startup excuse. We're a startup, we're lean, we have to do it this way. everybody has to do everything. Everybody has to pull their weight. When one person's not there, someone else has got to fit walk in and and fill the gap. Right. So these are, you know, viable, you know, real challenges for startups. it's a startup mentality.

And we don't want to dismiss the realities of a growing business. You know, there are constraints, of course there are. and startups do need people that can turn their hand to different tasks. So you want to be looking for hiring people that do have a variety, they can spread themselves a little bit wider, right? And yes, budgets are tight, of course, and nobody can hire an expert at everything. So you're not going to have that dream.

position of an expert in every role and that's all they do. That's not going to happen with a startup, of course. but adaptability isn't the same as aptitude. So people can be adaptable, but if they really can't do a particular job, they can't do a particular job. Let me give you an example would be, for example, a very introverted person, and you put them in a sales role and you make them go and speak to people all day, every day. That's going to be hell on earth for them.

Ange Dove (11:45)

Right, you would not put them in that role. And if you do, they're not going to stay very long. And there's a difference between a skills gap that can be closed with training, right? And just a fundamental mismatch that no matter how hard you train them, how well you train them, how long you train them, they're just never going to be able to do the job. So you've got to be able to recognize when it's a mismatch and when it's something that, yeah, with a little bit of training, this person could fall into line with this role, right?

And then having everyone responsible for everything is just chaos waiting to happen, quite frankly. So, yes, wearing multiple hats is a part of startup life, of course it is, but you still need to know which hats people should be wearing and they can't wear them all. Just note that from the start, they can't wear them all. So, what you want how do you do you handle this while still keeping your costs as low as possible?

You want to build a team through the strengths, not just through job descriptions, right? So you want to identify, really sit down and look at your team and think about what each person naturally does well. Now there are actual actual capability tools out there that you can get your staff to take these tests that will actually report for you what this person is naturally good at, just because they're personality type, right?

So identify what each of your team does naturally well and not just what they're currently doing. So, for example, if someone has been put in a role as a marketing person, but they're actually a tech geek and they do things all around tech in marketing on the side or in a side hustle, whatever, and they have the knowledge and the interest.

in all the tech, you probably want that person to be handling some of the tech stuff for you rather than trying to train a newbie up to handle the tech for you, that kind of thing. You need to be sensible in your decisions with this, right? So identify what each does well, not just what they're currently doing. Look at their energy as well as their output. What work brings out their best? Where do they shine? Where did they really come alive? When do

Ange Dove (14:15)

Does their eyes light up when they talk about something? Notice these things because you could have a hidden jewel in your team and you don't know about it, but they could be really good at something that you're just not applying them to. And you put that person in the role and your business source. Right. Then as you want to do with even your job descriptions as well, when you're putting your job descriptions out in the market to try and find people, you need to define the outcomes of each role.

that they need to deliver on. And that should be in your job descriptions as well. So the better your job descriptions when you apply for people to to advertise for people to come into a company, the better quality of people that are going to answer those. And you'll naturally filter out the ones that get a bit intimidated by the job description. If it's not for them, they probably won't apply.

And then you want to distinguish between someone who needs support, as I've hinted at before, and someone who fundamentally just will never be able to do that role. Right. So look at where what they do, who is more likely when if you've got a gap and you need to fill a role in a company, you've got a gap, look at all your people that you have. And who is likely to be able to do that work with a little bit of training? You give them enough to for them to be able to do it and they will naturally be able to take it on. It might not be their greatest strength, but they're going to be capable and competent at doing it. As opposed to trying to put that person into the role or trying to put another person into the role that no matter how long you train them, they're never going to be able to do it. Right. Don't do that.

And don't mistake loyalty for suitability as well. They may really, really want to work with you, but if none of the roles are suitable, then should they be with you at all, right? so the best teams aren't aren't made up of people who can do everything. They're made up of people whose strengths complement one another. Okay.

Ange Dove (16:27)

That's what you want to be doing as the leader of your business. Understand who your team is, what they're capable of, what they can be more capable of if with a little bit of training, and what that you should never put them in because it's either going to be detrimental to your business or you're going to lose them. I'll give you an example of that. one of the first people I hired was in an admin position and she was absolutely excellent.

At that position. She could do everything, you know. I didn't have to train her on anything. She could just walk in. She could do it. So this was like sending quotes, dealing with invoices, chasing up customers to be paid, answering emails as they came in, answering the telephone. She was great at all that kind of thing. And then but I didn't realize at the time that not everybody is the same, right? And different people, different personality types like to do work a different way, right? So what I didn't realize about her was that although she was brilliant at what she was doing, I just assumed that then she'd be brilliant at the next thing I gave her, right? And what I didn't realize was that the reason she was brilliant at what she was doing was the job fitted her personality type perfectly. And she was someone who just wanted routine, everything to be the same every day, no surprises.

Just everything consistent and a pattern and she wa she was just happy being able to serve that role day in, day out, same thing every day.

To me, that role would then be hell on earth because I would want var variety. I want something different every day. but I didn't realise at the time that she didn't think the same way as me. So I try to give her I I was actually racking my brains trying to think of what else can I give her that's gonna make her day more exciting. She didn't want her day to be more exciting. So I gave her more exciting things to do. what happened?

Ange Dove (18:38)

within a month or so she handed in her resignation and she left. So if you force people to do things that are not within their capabilities, they are going to make a choice. You first of all you're going to make them miserable and they'll try to serve, they'll try to keep up, and then eventually you're just going to destroy their soul and they will leave and go and find a job that suits what they want to do. So just be aware of that as well.

So, Part of being a leader in your company as well and hiring staff and leading leading a team is having difficult conversations when things don't go to plan and you're realizing that things are messed up and you need to correct them. You to get that correction done, you need to have difficult conversations. So really that's your accountability, right? This is the role for you as a leader that you've got to lead these conversations. And take responsibility for the fact that you made a mistake when you hired. It it's not your fault. It was something you didn't realize at the time, but now you know, and now you can do something about it. So you want to have the courage to admit that you made the wrong decision. And why keeping someone that's unsuitable for the role isn't an act of kindness. It it's just keeping someone in a position they're not happy with, and then it affects all the other people in the team.

They're also not happy, you might end up everybody leaving in in that sense. So you need to nip it in the bud when you do realize you made a mistake. Either move them to a different role or you've got to let them go. So discuss the choices with them. What do they want to do? You know, just be honest with them. It's just I thought you were able to do this and I realize now this was my mistake. I put you into this role and I realize now it's not really made for you.

Then you want to discuss with them, do you retrain them to do something that they can do? If something, if there's some role in your company that would be suited to them with a little bit of extra training, that could be a solution. redistribute their responsibilities so that other members of the team are taking on the parts that they are not comfortable doing, and you leave them with the part that they can do, and then maybe combine.

Ange Dove (21:02)

the capabilities they have with another role. So again, you're redistributing the roles between your team members so that it's more balanced as to what everybody's doing according to their capabilities. You want to redesign the role completely, redeploy the the person to a different role, or worst case scenario, if there's absolutely nothing you can do to make them fit anywhere, then it would be a case of you'd you would have to let them go.

So just remember that is it that is a difficult decision, of course, to make, but it's n it's an act of kindness sometimes to let someone go rather than make them miserable working for you in a job that that they absolutely hate. Right. But you have to have an honest conversation with them first to find out, you know, you might find out in that conversation what they are more suitable to do if you actually ask them what is it that you would like to do.

And then you find out you might find out something about them you didn't know before. And then it could be, well, you could do this, right? So have a conversation first and find out how you can better position them within the company. All right. So the right people in the right roles is really what we're talking about. Don't put square pegs in round holes. We learned as children that doesn't work. We need to learn as business owners.

Tthat it still doesn't work in business as well. So building a team isn't about finding people that will say yes to everything that you ask them to do. It's about understanding what people are naturally good at and what lights them up, what gives them energy. Basically essentially what you want to be f really identifying is what energizes people and what drains them. Because if they're doing work that drains them, they're no good to your business. If they're doing work that energizes them.

They're going to move your business forward. So you need to be putting the people in roles that will energize them. Just think of it as an energy thing. And I think it'll be easier for you to make the decisions then. So understand what they're good at, what gives them energy, and give them the opportunity to excel at that. And just because you're a startup, you're not a multinational company, you're a startup. Yes, people have to.

Ange Dove (23:27)

pull their weight and do different things, but you still have to make sure you're distributing those roles so that they may be spread thin, but they are still capable within that landscape. And then other people over here may be spread thin, but they're good within that landscape. Right. Don't put don't cross them over. Right. Because as I said at the beginning, you you you put them in the wrong wrong roles.

It's going to affect them. It's going to affect the team members that are working with them. It's going to affect the company because the customers are going to notice and your productivity is going to be off. So you're not doing anyone any favors by trying to put someone in the wrong role. All right. So this is what I'd encourage you to think about. Look at the people in your team, including yourself, and ask, are they in the role where they can make the greatest contribution and where they can give the greatest energy? or have you simply put them there to fill a gap that needed filling? Don't do that, right? good leadership isn't about forcing people to fit a job. It's about building a team where the right people are doing their best work.

And that's something worth thinking about when you're the boss. So if you've liked what you've heard today and you think this is useful for you and you'd like to follow this podcast, then do subscribe, ring the bell so you know when the next one's going out. If you found this particular episode useful, then do share it with other business owners that you know or maybe they're struggling with building a team and they needed to hear this today. Until next time, bye for now.

Don't leave without your free gifts

Check out my page of freebies designed to help you make progress towards your goals.

From free training on making $10,000 months to how to create your brand message to access to the resources I use in my business that may help you too!

I've got some

gifts for you!

Check out my page of freebies designed to help you make progress towards your goals.

From free training on making $10,000 months to how to create your brand message to access to the resources I use in my business that may help you too!

About me

Hi there 👋 My name is Ange Dove, professional copywriter and messaging strategist. I help Gen X professionals find the words to express who they have become, and to build a career or business that owns it.

GET YOUR UNCHAINED AUDIT

Let’s have coffee online for 60 minutes on Zoom, where we'll look at your profile, your message, and your next chapter together and give you the roadmap to take your next steps.

GET THE NEWSLETTER

Straight-talking insights for experienced professionals who want to turn what they know into income, options and greater freedom over what comes next.